Classic Google vs Perplexity, Chat GPT & Meta AI

33 min
Guest:
None
Episode
106
We've done three different searches on classic Google search and compared the results to what Perplexity, Chat GPT and Meta A.I have to say. We're told AI is a Google killer, so is it now, and will it be in the future? This episode digs in to try and find out.
Connect with Michael:
on Twitter @servicescaling
on Instagram @cos71n
on Linkedin
his personal website.

Connect with Arthur:
his personal website
on LinkedIn

Watch our YouTube:
We're posting @watchtheseoshow

Our SEO agency:
Check out our agency Local Digital
Follow our agency Local Digital on Instagram @localdigitalco
Check out our content on Youtube

Show Notes

In this episode of The SEO Show, Michael and Arthur dive deep into the evolving landscape of search engines, particularly in the context of the rising influence of AI technologies. We kick off the episode with a light-hearted introduction, where I attempt a quirky voice impression, which Arthur humorously critiques.

As we transition into the main topic, we discuss the current state of search engines, particularly Google, and how AI is perceived as a potential threat to its dominance. With the rapid advancements in AI, many speculate that traditional search engines may soon become obsolete. We explore this notion by comparing Google with several AI-driven platforms, including perplexity.ai, ChatGPT, and Meta AI.

Throughout the episode, we conduct a series of practical searches to evaluate the performance and user experience of these platforms. We start with a local business search for "plumber near me," where we analyse the results from Google, which provides a comprehensive list of ads, local packs, and organic search results. In contrast, perplexity.ai and ChatGPT offer less satisfactory experiences, often failing to deliver relevant or actionable information.

We also examine the implications of AI on traditional directories like Yellow Pages and Air Tasker, pondering whether these services could be rendered obsolete by AI's ability to provide direct answers. The conversation shifts to Eric Schmidt's perspective on the future of Google, emphasising that AI will change how information is organised and accessed.

As we continue our comparisons, we search for "cheap family holiday in Europe." Google excels with a variety of options and resources, while perplexity.ai struggles to understand the query, returning irrelevant results focused on local accommodations instead of European destinations. ChatGPT and Meta AI also fall short, with responses that lack depth and specificity.

In a more technical search regarding how to replace a 2019 Volkswagen Amarok battery, we find that both Google and perplexity.ai provide useful step-by-step instructions, but ChatGPT and Meta AI lag behind in delivering practical information.

Throughout the episode, we reflect on the potential future of search engines, discussing how AI could evolve to provide better, more personalised results. I share my own experiences using AI for technical queries, highlighting its usefulness as an assistant for specific tasks rather than a replacement for traditional search methods.

As we wrap up, we touch on the importance of having options in search results and the potential biases that could arise from AI-driven answers. We conclude with a light-hearted reference to Seinfeld, tying our discussion back to pop culture, and leave our listeners with thoughts on the future of SEO and search engines.

Join us for this engaging exploration of AI's impact on search, and discover why, for now, Google still reigns supreme in the world of online information retrieval.

00:00:00 - Introduction to the SEO Show
Michael introduces the podcast and invites listeners to seek a second opinion on their SEO.

00:00:17 - Meet the Hosts
Michael and Arthur introduce themselves and discuss their quirky intro attempts.

00:01:25 - AI vs. Google: The Current Landscape
The hosts discuss the impact of AI on search engines and the potential future of Google.

00:02:40 - Eric Schmidt's Perspective
Discussion on Eric Schmidt's comments about the evolution of Google and AI's role in providing answers.

00:04:40 - Local Business Search: Google vs. AI
The hosts compare the experience of searching for a plumber using Google and various AI platforms.

00:10:05 - Perplexity.ai Experience
Analysis of the search results for "plumber near me" using Perplexity.ai.

00:11:23 - ChatGPT's Response
Review of ChatGPT's performance when asked for local plumber recommendations.

00:12:43 - Meta AI's Search Results
Exploration of the results provided by Meta AI for finding a plumber.

00:13:53 - Impact on Traditional Directories
Discussion on how AI could affect businesses like Air Tasker and Yellow Pages.

00:14:38 - Searching for Family Holidays
The hosts analyse the search results for "cheap family holiday in Europe" using Google.

00:20:58 - Perplexity.ai for Holiday Searches
Review of the results from Perplexity.ai for the same holiday search.

00:22:04 - ChatGPT's Holiday Recommendations
Evaluation of ChatGPT's suggestions for budget-friendly family holidays in Europe.

00:23:46 - Meta AI's Holiday Suggestions
Discussion on the results provided by Meta AI for family holiday searches.

00:24:56 - How to Replace a Car Battery
The hosts compare search results for replacing a Volkswagen Amarok battery across different platforms.

00:30:02 - The Future of AI in Search
Discussion on the potential future of AI in search and its implications for SEO.

00:31:53 - Seinfeld Reference and Conclusion
The hosts wrap up the episode with a light-hearted Seinfeld reference and conclude the discussion.

Transcript

MICHAEL:
Hi guys, Michael here. Do you want a second opinion on your SEO? Head to theseoshow.co and hit the link in the header. We'll take a look under the hood at your SEO, your competitors and your market and tell you how you can improve. All right, let's get into the show.

INTRO: It's time for the SEO show where a couple of nerds talk search engine optimization so you can learn to compete in Google and grow your business online. Now here's your hosts, Michael and Arthur.

MICHAEL: Howdy how. I'm Michael Costin. And I'm Arthur. And that was my attempt at doing, what was the little poo from South Park called? Mr. Hankey? Yeah. But I didn't really want to go high pitched. I wanted to keep my normal voice, just put my own spin on it. That was your normal voice?

ARTHUR: Kind of. Yeah. It was very weird. You did the hand motion and everything for those, obviously people can't see you, but I really hope you never do that in true again.

MICHAEL: All right, I won't, but every episode from now on is a new intro. You've told me to bring my A-game.

ARTHUR: Yep, I also told you that every episode we have to somewhat relate back to Seinfeld.

MICHAEL: And we will, at some point this episode we'll drop a Seinfeld reference. Have you thought about it? No, it's just going to come naturally. Okay. And then if it doesn't, I'll shoehorn something in at the end. All right. But this week we've got a little bit of a comparison episode, because Everyone knows that in the AI mania, the feeding frenzy that's going on at the moment, we're being told that, you know, it's a threat to Google. AI is sort of replacing searches that people do. And in two, three years time, Google might not exist as we know it anymore. And that AI is going to be used for everything. Probably true to an extent, yes.

ARTHUR: I don't want to interrupt, but I just did. Meta's integrated AI into all their search now on Facebook and stuff. So basically, like, it's there.

MICHAEL: It's there. And that would, well, to give you a bit of an anecdotal, feedback like my wife was on there trying to look something up and was getting infuriated that she couldn't just search for a page on Facebook because it was a meta AI and you had to be like go down and click like load more or see results or something and they fix that now so that it does show like pages but I don't know I feel like they're sort of shoehorning that into their products Is it a good experience? That's what this episode is about, because what we've basically done is we're looking at Google, as we know it right now. We're looking at perplexity.ai, which is a AI-based search engine. Google killer, as they call it. We're looking at chat GPT and we're looking at meta AI. So those four. And we've run a few different search terms that people might do through each of them and logged what the experience is like. And we're going to give our feedback on where we think Google, as we know it, is better, where maybe AI is a threat. And yes, we know at the moment AI is very new. It's changing every six months. Something new comes along. There's always going to be potential for some big killer to come along. But what we've seen is not really that much in favor of AI, in my opinion, anyway. But we'll get into it. But before we get into it, I want to talk about old mate Eric Schmidt. Schmidt? Schmidt. He used to be the CEO of Google. So he was when Sergey and Larry, Sergey and Larry, you know my mates, Sergey and Larry. Yeah.

ARTHUR: Friends of the show.

MICHAEL: Friends of the show. Needed like a CEO to come in. He was a dude that came in and helped them like massively grow their ad business blah blah blah and he says Google is not about blue links. It's about organizing the world's information. So he was just on CNBC like yesterday. He said that and Yeah. So he's saying that Google is changing in the new world, AI will provide answers. There won't be a list of websites for people to click on and find the answer for themselves. That's it. You just, AI will be, you ask it a question, it tells you. Yeah. So that opens up like questions about bias and like. Or massively. And we've already seen with Gemini how biased its answers are, like against certain politicians but for others, against certain viewpoints but for others. They have the power to be very biased with their results here. I think that's a massive red flag.

ARTHUR: It's a massive problem.

MICHAEL: But is it also a good experience to just have AI tell you what it thinks? Well, that's sort of what we've tried to look at with these little searches that we've done. I don't necessarily think that it is. So I know he's very bullish, but he's probably invested in NVIDIA.

ARTHUR: I'll give you my experience with AI and what I use it for, like religiously, after.

MICHAEL: Okay. So what I tried to do is I wanted to look, I did a local business type search. I did a family holiday planning type search. And then I did an informational, like a how-to type search.

ARTHUR: I might do it along with you, because I didn't do it.

MICHAEL: OK. And I did it on all of them. So the first one, let's start with a local business search. So Eric Schmidt, the former CEO of Google, is telling us that Google is not going to be a list of links anymore where you can find your own information. You're just going to type in a question, and AI gives you an answer. So I wrote Plummer Near Me. First, I went to Google and it loads instantly. You type something in, the results come. In this case, I got four ads. Google loves ads, so four ads. Then I saw three local pack results in the Maps pack. Then I saw two people also ask. Then I got nine organic search results, the glorious SEO world, or the local pack's SEO as well. Then I got one ad at the end, eight related searches. That's what I see, exactly that. And then the ads are for businesses that are plumbers that serve my area, and the local pack was plumbers near me, and the organic search listings were a bunch of plumbers near me. First one for me, Yellow Pages.

ARTHUR: Well, there you go. Same thing, but yeah.

MICHAEL: So that's a typical Google experience that we all know and or love to a certain degree. Love might be like or loathe depending on your take on Google. But to me, that's a pretty good experience to find a plumber near you.

ARTHUR: I just had a thought. Yeah. We're talking about how this might affect Google, but how might this affect something like Air Tasker or Yellow Pages? They'd be wiped out. Yeah, because if you're getting the results straight within the AI, like whatever chat, it basically bypasses the need to use any kind of directory like that.

MICHAEL: Yeah. See, coming back to Eric Schmidt, Google is not about blue links. It's about organizing the world's information. Where we're headed with AI, they're not organizing the world's information. They are scraping it all, training the AI off it, using it all, and then killing those creators that create that information and just giving the answer in their AI. They'll monetize it and Long term, where does the creation of new information come from? If people are being killed by Google walling off?

ARTHUR: Well, AI is creating all the new information too.

MICHAEL: It hallucinates, yeah. So, I don't know. It's not good. It's like, to me, the potential downsides of this are worse than the benefit of supposedly having AI just give you an answer. Massively. Let's jump into the AI answers, because we all know a Google experience searching for a plumber. From where I stand, instant results. You get a whole bunch of different plumbers. You can click into them, contact the ones you like the look of. Right.

ARTHUR: So what's the first one?

MICHAEL: Perplexity. Perplexity.ai. So I'm going to do a search now while you talk. Yeah. So I did the same search in that. Plumber near me. Now, I hit a little timer from when I hit search to when the results were being displayed. Because for me with Gen AI, sitting around waiting for it to come up with the answer can be a bit annoying sometimes. So it took 10.25 seconds for me hitting the search button to the results being displayed. And what it did was it recommended four different plumbers with a recap of content that it found on the site. So it says, This plumber's number one, it has five star rating, 30 years experience. It's just rehashing stuff it found on the plumber's website. Then at the end, it gave three times related searches. And then on the right hand side, it has like a map panel. When you click into it, it lists all random plumbers in Sydney on a map. If you click those plumbers names, it will just zoom in on them on the map, but you can't actually click through to a website.

ARTHUR: Or see the reviews. Yeah. So it tells you that there's, for example, 50 reviews, 4.9 stars, but from what I see, you can't really, you can't read them from within this search kind of box.

MICHAEL: So it, it, it gives it trick. And what I found is if I searched plumber near me two or three times, the plumbers that it's recommending change each time.

ARTHUR: Well, what I'm seeing here is it's, it's giving me the sources. So it's giving me three plumbers, but what it's doing, it's, it's pulling information from those pages. So it's not really recommending it. And I think it's gotten confused because it's talking as if plumbers near me is a business. So it's saying plumbers near me, Sydney offers 24 seven emergency plumbing. I'm probably sure there's a plumber called plumbers near me who bought the exact match domain. Yes. So that's a horrific experience.

MICHAEL: In my opinion. Yep. So you have to wait 10 seconds first and foremost for it to be displayed. Yeah. And you can click through to its recommendations, but that's it. And then you're only getting four as opposed to the Google results, which have four ads, three local pack, nine organic listings, another ad at the end. So look for me, that's a win for Google over perplexity.

ARTHUR: Yeah. And on top of that, it's also showing plumbers in North Sydney, which is not near me. Yeah. So exactly.

MICHAEL: Yeah. So it's whoever's using plumbers near me on their site well enough to get the AI to think that it should display you for that term. Yeah. So let's jump over to our friend chat GPT. What happens when we type plumber near me into chat GPT? Well, 8.28 seconds from hitting search, later than eight seconds later, we have a display of results. And it says, to find a plumber near you, I recommend using online directories such as Google Maps, Yelp or local business listings. Simply type plumber near me into the search bar and it should provide you with a list of available plumbing services in your area. So chat GPTs telling you how to use Google.

ARTHUR: Well, my, funnily enough, mine's a bit different. So initially I accidentally did it in 3.5 and it came back with like finding, bless you. Finding a plumber nearby is often best done through blah, blah, blah, explaining what you said. But if you do it in four, chat GPT four.

MICHAEL: That was four that I did it in.

ARTHUR: Yeah, so it's saying to help you find a plumber, I'll need to know your current location. Can you please provide the city and area where you're looking for a plumbing service? So let's just humor it and put in where we are. So for finding a plumber in where we are, I recommend checking out- Generating, yeah. Go search Google. Yeah, there you go. That's a win for Google right there.

MICHAEL: That's to say, so far Google's beating Perplexity and ChatGVT. Let's see what Meta AI has to bring to the party. So I went into WhatsApp. I typed in plumber near me. It took 32.22 seconds to generate the results. So I wrote Plumber Near Me, and it goes, great. I'd be happy to help you find a reliable plumber. Could you please share your city or zip code with me so I can provide you with more accurate results? So I just wrote Parramatta, where our office is. Then it recommended me dial up plumbing services. And it just says, like, they've been providing top notch services to residents of Parra for 20 years. And it's just basically saying they can do same day service and that sort of stuff. So it's given one result, it's a random plumber. At the end it references Bing, so it shows a Bing link for a search result plumber near Parramatta. If I click that, it takes me to Bing and those search results, the plumber that the AI is recommending is not in the maps or the organic results for the search plumber near Parramatta. Right. So who knows where it's pulled it from.

ARTHUR: So basically what we're finding here is that for any sort of search like servicing, sorry, searching for a service or business, it's trash.

MICHAEL: I think so. But like this meta one is, The concerning one, because it's just recommending one plumber, and we don't know how it's found them, or why it's recommending them, and when you go and look in the search results, there's lists of, like, really well-reviewed, strong plumbing businesses, and this one… Well, that's how it's going to work in the future, like, instead of having Google Ads and ads showing up, it'll be whoever's bidding will come up in the AI.

ARTHUR: As the one single answer. That's most likely.

MICHAEL: That's a scary future for businesses.

ARTHUR: I mean, it's not too different to what I guess Google ads is anywhere, right? Like you could be the shittest plumber in the world, but if you've got enough money, you'll be first.

MICHAEL: Correct, but you also have other ads around and organic and options for people. Yeah, yeah. What this old schmitty boy was saying is that there's not going to be a list of results.

ARTHUR: I don't know what it would be like to be called schmitty boy.

MICHAEL: Well, that's what I'm doing. Schmitty parmigiana. All right, let's move on to the next one. Cheap family holiday in Europe. Yep. That's the keyword because people, you know, they want to find cheap options. So if I go to Google and type cheap family holiday in Europe, hit enter, bang, the results are there. What I saw, the first result was a KidSpot article where a mum saved 10 grand. Yeah, that's what I see. Pretty good, saving 10 grand on your cheap holiday. There's all pointers in it.

ARTHUR: Yeah.

MICHAEL: People also ask, it has, where is the cheapest place to holiday in Europe? Where's the cheapest place for family holiday? If you click into one of them, it's recommending countries like Bulgaria and Albania and stuff. Makes sense, they're probably cheaper than Italy and France. Then it says which Europe country is suitable for kids, so I guess that's not really the intent, but… If you move down into the results, then there's a Guardian article on best budget beach holidays in Europe. There's Europe holiday deals. That sort of implies cheap. Flight center. Yep. So good. Decent starting point, right?

ARTHUR: Yeah. It gives you a lot of options to have a look at different things. Like if you want to find out countries, for example, you can go find a list of countries and start researching from there. If you want to find deals, you can go to flight center. So you have the option based on the intent to do what you want to do.

MICHAEL: Yep. So, in Schmidiboy's world, this won't exist in the future. There won't be links. It's just AI will give you the answer. You type cheap family holiday in Europe, you get your answer. Maybe you have to go back and forth with the AI. Yeah. So, let's have a look at that world, perplexity. So, I'd put the exact same keyword into perplexity. It took 9.4 seconds to complete the results. Okay. So, it gave me eight recommendations. So the first six recommendations were for hotels and budget friendly accommodation in Sydney and then Paddington and Chippendale, which are suburbs of Sydney. Yep. That's not Europe. So I'm just loading. That's a, that's a total fail to begin with the map results on the right hand side. We're all showing Sydney accommodation. And then I said it gave eight recommendations, so the first six were for Sydney. The last two were referring to tour radar and intrepid travel offering tours in Europe, so sure. And then a Guardian article of budget beach friendly holidays, which is the same article that was returned in the Google search results. So let's look at that experience. I've gone to Google and typed in cheap family holiday. You get that results that sort of give you countries and options and articles on women that save money on holidays. You go to Perplexity, ask it for cheap Europe holiday with kids, and it's giving you hostels and hotels in Sydney, Paddington, and Chippendale. So the AI was not understanding what I was asking it. So not a great experience. What are you seeing there in Perplexity? Was it something similar or something different?

ARTHUR: Yeah, so it's pulling up the sources as hotels here in Sydney, so like the Capsule Hotel, Edina, 28 Hotel. The first, like, Answer it provides budget friendly destinations it actually does pull in like Bulgaria, Puglia, Italy. Puglia, sorry. And then Croatia. So I guess cheaper than your average European country. But then when it talks about affordable accommodation, it starts talking about Sydney accommodation. So it's talking about Oxford House in Paddington. I think that's what you mentioned. Budget tour operators. So it's talking about tour radar, which has over 250 family tours in Europe, which is okay. Like it's telling you where you can get budget tours. And then Intrepid Travel, another one which offers family-friendly tours, so that's okay. Then it kind of gives you some like tips for saving money, which is like very basic. Avoiding peak prices, obviously. Look for self-catering accommodation. Take advantage of free attractions, like no shit. And use public transport instead of taxis. I think most people would know that already, so it's not very useful. But then it's got the related, like you said, what are some affordable family-friendly destinations in Europe. So you can click into that. Whether or not the, it's very slow, like you said.

MICHAEL: You've got to sit there and wait for it to generate after it telling you to go to Sydney hotels for a cheap family holiday in Europe.

ARTHUR: Yeah, so for that search for family-friendly destinations, the first thing is Europe Grill, which is, I think, a restaurant here in Newtown. So, again, wrong.

MICHAEL: Now, perplexity is new, it will get better. But it's not, you wouldn't use this, like, this is not… It's a horrible experience, like, just the time, like, waiting 10 seconds for results to show. Look shocked there, like… Hey, you ready for something shocking? ChatGPT took 25 seconds. Well, I think that might be your internet connection. Let me try. No. It's from when you click generate and it starts writing. You got to sit there and watch it write for 25 seconds. I'm going to put my timer on and we'll talk about it. I'll do that. I did cheap family holiday in Europe and it goes, finding a budget friendly family holiday in Europe can be both exciting and economical. So you've got to deal with its annoying waffle that ChatGPT is fond of. So what it recommended was a few countries. Portugal, that's cheap, apparently. Greece. Now it does say going to the less popular islands rather than Santorini or Mykonos, sure, but I wouldn't say Greek islands are a budget-friendly holiday for a family at all. Croatia, Bulgaria, Czech Republic. So it's saying beyond Prague, go to other cities, I can't even pronounce it, Český Krumlov or something. Bulgaria, sure, so that would be cheap. And then it's saying, tips, travel off peak, book in advance, go self-catering, take public transport, look for free activities.

ARTHUR: Yeah. 20, sorry to interrupt, 27 seconds to generate that response. But I think in GPT's defense, you're reading it and it's, as it's generating it, you're reading it. So you're not waiting there for like a 20, it's not like a page loading in 28 seconds, but it is, it is slow. Yeah.

MICHAEL: Is generative AI a good experience to search for this stuff, like Schmidty's saying? At the moment, it's not. In the future, perhaps.

ARTHUR: This is a good way to find locations to start searching for accommodation prices and stuff. So, for someone that doesn't know anything about Europe, who might not have traveled there, or Yep. To get a list of places like Portugal, Croatia, Bulgaria, like, I guess most people when they think of Europe would think of like France, Italy, you know, like you said, Greece. Yep. They're like the, you know, more. expensive countries, so to get a list and a starting point, definitely a lot more useful than what perplexity provided.

MICHAEL: But if I go, let's go back to the Google search, cheap family holiday in Europe, pre-scroll down in the people also ask.

ARTHUR: Oh, Google trumps it, I'm not saying it doesn't, I'm just saying it's not as bad as what perplexity generated.

MICHAEL: Yeah, but just to give an example of how much better I think Google is at the moment, No, I agree. Cheap family holiday in Europe. The first results that KidsSpot thing, but in the people also ask, the first thing is where is the cheapest place to holiday in Europe? It recommends Bulgaria, Albania, Montenegro, Hungary, Slovenia, Portugal, the Czech Republic, Estonia, bang, bang, bang. You can do your digging on that and it happens instantly. That's probably where Chad got that.

ARTHUR: Yeah. Because it's very similar other than like one or two countries. Yeah.

MICHAEL: So what about meta AI? So I went to WhatsApp, typed the same search in. In eight seconds later, I got results that said you can go to Porto in Portugal because you can walk and it's free. You can go to Seville in Spain. They've got stables and farms where you can ride horses for free. Apparently, I don't know, cheap maybe? I don't know.

ARTHUR: Or not.

MICHAEL: I'd say steal a horse. Roads in Greece, it's an island with many beaches and shallow waters, making it a great option for families with kitties. Budapest, Hungary, it has a children's railway. It's operated entirely by children. That sounds illegal. Yeah, I know. And so it was pulling all of that from Bing. So look, they're good ideas to start the search process a bit more, but I wouldn't want to give myself over to AI when looking for something like that.

ARTHUR: No, not at all.

MICHAEL: All right, this last one is one where I think AI did possibly a better job than Google. Yeah, I think, yeah. How to, it was a how to question. Yep. So the prompt I put in was how to replace 2019 Volkswagen Amarok battery. So when I went to Google, typed that in, the very first thing I saw was a featured snippet where it's just scraping auto trade of South Africa. And it gives you seven steps on how to change the battery, open the bonnet, find the battery, remove the negative. Was there a video? Remove the positive. Well, this is just this featured snippet with text. Beneath that is a video where it has VW Amarok battery removal and replacement. So it's a YouTube video. It's got all the chapter markers for it. Yeah, that's handy. Yeah, and then it's got other videos below that. Then it has four people also ask, five organic results. One is on how to do it, three is for purchasing batteries, one is for a Facebook owners group for Amarok. Pretty good. Then there's three images, one sponsored ad at the end, four related searches. So that's bang. Good. Like if you're confident enough with tools and all that, it's telling you to use, you know, 12 mil spanner, remove, it's just a text rundown of how to do it, bang.

ARTHUR: Yeah, pretty good. But then you get the video demonstrating how to do it. Then you've got your results organic with a site that has instructions on how to do it. And then if you need to replace it, options to buy the battery. And then a group if you need to potentially ask questions. So you can't ask for more than that.

MICHAEL: That's not perfect. And it happens instantly when you search it. Yeah. So let's go to Perplexity AI. It took them six seconds to render the results, so that was the quickest that they achieved in all of these. So it gives a nice concise text explainer where it gives you nine steps on how to do it. Quite similar to Googling that it's saying use a 12mm socket to remove it, remove a 10mm spanner to remove the bracket, so all very good. To the right, it also has YouTube videos, the same YouTube videos as the Google search result. And it also has sources for that, which are all how-to guides that you can click through to. And then just images of where the batteries are in the engine bay. So I thought like, the reason I thought this one's good is the featured snippet for Google, the steps are very concise. Open the bonnet, locate battery, use 12 mil to remove negative, unclip positive. Remove the bracket. Exchange battery. Assemble in reverse. Whereas if you go into perplexity, it's explaining why you might remove the negative first. And you've got to install the battery the right way around. So it sort of gives you a bit more context. And it also has a video there. So in this case, I could see maybe an argument for perplexity being better. But again, it takes six seconds to render results. And Google experience is pretty good. ChatGPT, 33.3 seconds to render results. You get the usual painful opening and closing paragraphs where it just adds waffle. Quite long step-by-step instructions, but there's no references, there's no photos or videos, it's just a text explainer. So, ChatGPT is not the right one. Meta, 15 seconds to render results, generic results, no reference to spanner sizes, no references to any sources or links to Bing or anything with that one. So, perplexity holds up to Google. So, either of them, I would say, are good. So, maybe in this case, Schmidiboy's future, where there is no list of links, you just get told what to do by AI. In this case, maybe. But in the earlier two examples, There's still a massive use case for Google, and I feel humans like us want the experience Google's giving at this point in time.

ARTHUR: So I'll tell you the way I use AI, chat GPT. Sure. You sound excited. Sure, show me. Thank you. Tell me, tell us. So basically, I guess I use it in the polar opposite. So when I don't want to sit there and sift through stuff, I'll give you some examples of searches that I've done in the last couple of days. So Google Ads API performance, how to integrate Google Ads API, like Ajax form tracking with GTM. So basically, it will, like ChatGPT4 is smart enough to actually provide instructions and is up to date that it can instruct you on how to do something without you having to go there and sift through potentially like garbage, rubbish articles, outdated articles, which, you know, for anyone that's doing marketing, everything gets outdated like that. So it gives you up-to-date information that you can just follow. I used it to like develop specific keys for things. And yeah, like it's a good way to kind of get information without having to, go through the tedious process. Technical, you know, creating formulas for Google Sheets or like assisting with creating an algorithm, you know, or like waiting specific things. So that's where I think the value lies in AI, like as an assistant, like a PA basically.

MICHAEL: Do you think it gets to the point, we've spoken about this before, where you just rely on whatever it tells you for searches like cheap Europe and best plumber, or do you want to do searching?

ARTHUR: Well, I want to do searching, but I can't speak for everyone else. I think that It's perfect for what I mentioned before, but when it comes to searching for like holidays, products, opinions and stuff like that, services, you should have the option to have a look and see. So like if generative AI was to provide you with the top 10 rated plumbers in Sydney, That's not a bad result.

MICHAEL: But perplexity tries to do that. It gives you four for plumbers, but they change each time you do it. And it's just based on random text that it pulls from the page. It's not actually figuring out what the best is.

ARTHUR: Yeah, but I mean, like in the future when it can actually accurately, like, determine which are the top 10, whether it's based on ratings or a combination of like authority, how long they've been around, how many reviews they have, and then actually give you the top 10 in your location. That's not a bad experience.

MICHAEL: No. So where do you see it heading? Like, do you think normal SEO will, when you just said then authority, reviews, how long it's been around, like some of that stuff is crossover with normal SEO.

ARTHUR: Yeah, it would probably be like SEO will still be SEO, but it'll just change or evolve. So rather than trying to rank first, you'll be trying to appear in the- One of the lists, one of the options in the list. Basically, that's the way I see it. And then Google ads will be the same thing. You'd be bidding to be at the top of the list. Yeah, it's not, as long as, like we talked about this again before we recorded, as long as you're getting options and it's not just bias and just providing you with one result. Like if you were to search for best lawyer in Sydney and it just gave you, this is the best lawyer in Sydney and it's someone that's just bid to be there, that isn't a good result. So as long as it's giving you options, then I think it's, it will like improve the search experience ultimately.

MICHAEL: Time will tell. The only thing is I just don't think sitting around waiting seconds for stuff to generate is ever a good experience.

ARTHUR: Quantum computing. But the other thing is that when you're doing searches for products, and we talked about this before, whenever I shop for shoes, I like looking at like, you know, I go to men's sneakers, whatever, like search by brand search, whatever. And I like to scroll through to see what there is. Like, I don't want Google to say, Hey, this is the perfect shoe for you. Cause I want to see what else to compare it to. So again, like, unless it's giving me an option, um, I still prefer the old fashioned way. But I mean, you know, people change, things change.

MICHAEL: Like- Yeah, yeah. Oh, look, we're in the very early days of this stuff and it could become amazing.

ARTHUR: People were against debit cards and whatever back in the day and like ATMs and all like, I want to go to a real person. And now ATMs are getting made redundant. So like stuff changes. So this is just the beginning. It's not ready at all. I think it's far off. Like, I think it's still years away before it becomes.

MICHAEL: It's being shoehorned, like AI is being shoehorned into everything. Like, I feel the meta and like you see it in Messenger. It's just a hot topic. I don't use it. Would you ever use that? Like.

ARTHUR: No, the only time I used the Meta-AI was to generate ridiculous images of like ducks and stuff to send to friends as like memes. But not for anything useful.

MICHAEL: Like chat is useful for grunt work. Yep. But as it comes to search for now, Google's winning. Classic. It's like classic Coke. Classic Coke's winning. And I don't know.

ARTHUR: You're a Pepsi Max person.

MICHAEL: Yes, I'm also a cereal person like Jerry from Seinfeld. No, you're not. No, it's my reference to Jerry because we haven't spoken about Seinfeld this episode.

ARTHUR: I wonder if Jerry's a Coke or Pepsi.

MICHAEL: He likes Snapple. Schnapple. Schnapples.

ARTHUR: What's that? Another cola?

MICHAEL: There's a little Schnapple juice thing that they always pull out of the fridge. No.

ARTHUR: Yeah. I don't pay that much attention.

MICHAEL: George likes Bosco, the chocolate sauce to put near his milk. Well, he likes Pepsi because he wanted to name his son Pepsi. Soda. He wanted to name his son Seven.

ARTHUR: Oh no, Pepsi's Simpsons. Yeah.

MICHAEL: And he was recommending that the other people, people that stole Seven, he wanted them to name their kids Seven.

ARTHUR: No, he likes Pepsi because he wanted to bring Pepsi to the dinner party instead of wine.

MICHAEL: Yeah. I'm a Pepsi guy too. So there you go. We've shoehorned that Seinfeld reference in. We'll do better next time. Maybe we can use AI to help us. Maybe. Time will tell, but that's another episode of the SEO Show in the books. We'll be back at some point in the future with another episode, but until then, happy perplexity AI-ing. And SEO-ing.

Most recent episodes

View all Episodes